Vis sammendrag
Competitive sport may offer an important context where peer acceptance and friendship can be established or hindered. The aim of this study is to build upon findings from Ommundsen et.al.,(2005) and examine the genuine impact of differential achievement goal variables and specific sub-dimensions of perfectionism upon indices of quality of peer relations among Norwegian soccer players. 1785 male (n= 1231) and female (n= 488) experienced soccer players (aged 12-19 years; Mean age = 14.9) taking part in the Norway cup international youth soccer tournament responded to a questionnaire (For measurements and psychometric details, see JSS; Ommundsen et.al., (2005). Results revealed that the predictor set of achievement striving variables were able to account for between 6 and 16% of variance in the peer relationship variables. In term of peer acceptance, a mastery climate (beta=.10, p<.001) and adaptive perfectionism as measured by personal standards (beta = .11, p<.001) were found to be positive predictors, whereas performance climate (beta = -.07, p<.01), maladaptive perfectionism in terms of doubt about action (beta = -.07, p<. 01), and concern over mistakes (beta = -.15, p<.001) were found to be negative predictors. In term of quality of friendship as measured by loyalty & free discussion, a mastery climate (beta=.15, p<.001), a task goal (beta =.11, p<.001), adaptive perfectionism as measured by personal standards (beta = .16, p<.001) were all found to be positive predictors, whereas the opposite pattern were found for maladaptive perfectionism in terms of parental expectations (beta= -.06, p<.05, parental criticism (beta= -.08, p <.01), doubt about action (beta = -.05, p<. 05), and concern over mistakes (beta = -.13, p<.001). In term of quality of friendship as measured by companionship, a mastery climate (beta=.14, p<.001), a task goal (beta =.10, p<.001), adaptive perfectionism in terms of personal standards (beta = .11, p<.001) were all found to be positive predictors, whereas negative predictors were maladaptive perfectionism as measured by parental expectations (beta= -.16, p<.001, doubt about action (beta = -.06, p<. 05), and concern over mistakes (beta = -.14, p<.001. In terms of low quality of friendship as measured by conflict in friendship, an ego goal (beta =.07, p<.001), maladaptive perfectionism in terms of parental expectations (beta = .14, p<.001, and concern over mistakes (beta = .08, p<.01) were found to be positive predictors, whereas negative predictors were a task goal (beta = -.06, p<.01), and adaptive perfectionism in terms of personal standards (beta = -.08, p<.001). Apparently, when players become preoccupied with being better than other team members, they may come to look upon each other as competitors within the team and be less willing to invest socially in each other to obtain team success at the expense of their own individual success. Further, maladaptive perfectionists being concerned about making mistakes, parental expectations and criticism as well as doubting their own achievement related actions may come to express anger towards fellow players for not performing up to perfectionist standards. This may in turn threaten the development of friendship and peer acceptance as well as bring young players into conflict with their team friends. Findings suggest that motivational and achievement striving patterns may impact on peer acceptance and quality of friendship relations in adolescent soccer.